By November 21, 2007 1 Comments Read More →

The Reviews You Never Get to Read

Almost out the door. But I did read a few good things today. Here’s one of them, a peek inside the little-known craft of writing reader’s reports. Think book reviews, but for a really small audience (and with a sometimes larger impact). From the Guardian (“Literature’s invisible arbiters,” by Esther Allen):

Worse, the power of a reader’s report is almost entirely negative. Barbara Epler of New Directions famously decided to publish the great WG Sebald on the strength of a negative reader’s report, but in general a bad report guarantees that a book won’t be published. A good report, however, is likely to be ignored. Worst of all, even when a good report does lead to publication – and the publisher finds a translator who’s up to the task – the translated book will probably be left to its own devices in the marketplace, with little or no publicity, and will therefore ultimately be deemed a failure. All of which leaves those of us who write reader’s reports in a rather ambiguous position.



About the Author:

Keir Graff is Executive Editor of Booklist Publications and the author of six books. His most recent is the middle-grade novel, The Phantom Tower (2018). Follow him on Twitter at @Booklist_Keir.

1 Comment on "The Reviews You Never Get to Read"

Trackback | Comments RSS Feed

  1. Jerry Gold says:

    Hi there Mr. Graff:

    How can I get a review on either of my two books?
    One is a short (27) story ( I’m Lost) about a ten year old boy lost in a big city and what happens to him. It’s written in English, Spanish and French.
    A Dog’s Life is a 427 page interracial love story with plenty of love making throughout. Both published through Amazon this year.
    Thank you,


Post a Comment